Song
Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus
The Tortured Poets Department · 2024 · Track 20
Sole author
Written byTaylor Swift, Aaron Dessner
Produced byTaylor Swift, Aaron Dessner
Also known as: COSOSOM
Motifs & symbols
Ghosts
Structural
Supernatural & Gothic
“Can we watch our phantoms like watching wild horses?”
Phantoms carry a theatrical and cinematic register here — spectral figures observed at a remove, like projections on a screen. The simile of wild horses adds an untameable quality to these ghostly presences; memory figured as something feral and uncontainable.
Community comment
Themes
What Might Have Been
Relationships
The speaker watches a former partner's new relationship from the outside and imagines the parallel life she might have had. The counterfactual is present tense and ongoing — she is watching someone else live the timeline she did not. 'Do you just not think about it?' is the haunting question at its centre.
Community comment
Sister Songs